Professional Curiosity Series · Week 47, 2026
The SEC's pay-disclosure proposal is not mainly about less disclosure. It is about who decides what is disclosed.
FalconBridge Partners · November 2026 · Own-account research, evidence date 16 November 2026
On 13 November 2026 the US Securities and Exchange Commission proposed rewriting the rule that governs executive pay disclosure, to make it “more principles-based and materiality-driven”.
We tested that against real proxy statements. Over half the named-executive pay disclosed today would leave the public record.
That is narrower than it sounds. The proposal is not adopted, it may change after comment, and for the two officers it would still cover, most of today's disclosure survives.
This piece is part of FalconBridge's Professional Curiosity series: questions we take up because they matter, research on our own account, and publish. It is not client work, and it draws on no client's confidential information.
We read the SEC's 542-page proposing release in full, including its rule text, and compared it with the current rule and the 2006 regime it would replace. We then took fifteen definitive proxy statements filed in 2026, across eleven industries, verified every named executive in them, and asked a plain question: if the proposed tables applied to these filings, who and what would still be disclosed?
15
2026 proxies
73
named executives
41
would cease to be named
52.1%
of disclosed pay removed
Share of $1,167.4 million in 2025 Summary Compensation Table pay that relates to executives who would cease to be named. Median by company: 44.4%.
The answer is concentrated in one place. The proposal would limit named executives to the principal executive and financial officers. In our sample, 41 of 73 named executives would cease to be named, and they account for 52.1% of the $1,167.4 million of 2025 pay disclosed. The SEC's own structured data points the same way: about 44% at larger filers and 25% at smaller ones. Those removed include business-unit heads, operating chiefs, general counsel and an executive chair.
What the proposal does well
For the two officers who remain, 33 of the 38 elements in today's four primary tables survive in some form. The single total is split into what was granted and what was earned, and investors would gain things they have asked for: a standardised realised-pay measure, award-by-award tracking and a reconciliation of non-GAAP targets.
Two things surprised us
1 · The second officer is often not the second-highest paid
The chief financial officer was the second-highest-paid executive at only 5 of 15 companies. At ten, someone who would leave the record earned more.
2 · The data used to measure the change would shrink too
The proposal would end the structured tagging of pay-versus-performance data that made our population check possible, and require new tagging only of the largest filers.
The deeper shift is in authority. Fifteen judgement points replace prescriptions, and the heaviest sit at the edge of the comparable tables: whether executive security counts as a perquisite at all, whether residual payments are material, and in which year equity is reported. In three of eight sample chief executives above the proposed $150,000 perquisite threshold, the security classification alone decides the outcome. Whether documented materiality policies would reduce scrutiny is something the evidence cannot yet tell us.
Our view, for what it is worth
The proposal relocates the decision about what to disclose from the rulebook to the boardroom. That is not good or bad in itself, but it means the useful work for a board starts now, before any final rule, and it is work only the company can do on its own proxy. A compensation committee might ask:
Who and what would leave our own record if this applied to our 2026 proxy?
Would we keep disclosing the executives who would cease to be named, and on what basis?
Could we show how each materiality judgement was made, if an investor asked?
These are questions, not advice. The decision about what to disclose, and whether to comment while the window is open, stays with each board and its counsel.
Our findings cover the public record at our evidence date. If it misses something you know, we would like to hear it.
The study behind this piece
The disclosure decision moves from the rulebook to the boardroom
The SEC's proposed Item 402 pay-disclosure reform
The study sets out its sources and the gaps it could not close.
Own-account research by FalconBridge Partners. Not based on client work or confidential information. Desktop research from public sources, evidence date 16 November 2026. Not investment, legal or tax advice.
Around this piece
USA · Week 47, 2026 · Jensen Huang resigns as Nvidia CEO; CFO Colette Kress named interim chief
More Professional Curiosity
A conversation about your decision
What needs to be understood
before your next decision?
Bring the proposition, question or direction you are working on. Together, we can define the support it requires.
Start a conversation